Federal mental health parity: the foundation
The Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA) of 2008, strengthened by the ACA in 2010, is the bedrock. The idea is simple: if your insurance plan offers mental health benefits, those benefits must be on par with medical and surgical benefits.
What that means in practice:
- If the plan covers medical procedures without prior authorization, it can’t require prior auth only for mental health treatments
- Deductibles, copays, and visit limits must be comparable between mental health and medical benefits
- Non-quantitative limits (like requiring medication failures before approving a procedure) can’t be applied more strictly for mental health than for medical treatments
What this means for TMS: If your insurer demands 4 failed medications before approving TMS but only requires 1 failed medication before a comparable medical procedure — say, surgery for back pain after failing physical therapy — that’s likely a parity violation.
This is a real lever. Use it.
States with strong TMS-relevant protections
No state mandates TMS coverage by name. But several have mental health coverage laws that make it much harder for insurers to deny you.
States with strong mental health mandates
- Requires coverage of all “medically necessary” mental health treatments
- SB 855 (2020) mandates that insurers use generally accepted standards of care — not their own restrictive criteria
- The Department of Managed Health Care actively enforces parity
- File complaints at: dmhc.ca.gov
- HB 19-1269 strengthened parity enforcement and required annual compliance reports from insurers
- Colorado Division of Insurance investigates parity complaints
- File complaints at: doi.colorado.gov
- One of the earliest and strongest mental health parity states
- Requires coverage of “biologically based mental illness” including depression
- Insurance commissioner has enforcement authority
- File complaints at: portal.ct.gov/CID
- Mental Health and Developmental Disabilities Code requires broad coverage
- Covers TMS explicitly when medically necessary for treatment-resistant depression
- File complaints at: insurance.illinois.gov
- Mental Health Parity Compliance law with a dedicated enforcement unit
- Maryland Insurance Administration conducts proactive parity audits — they don’t wait for complaints
- File complaints at: insurance.maryland.gov
- Requires coverage for all “biologically based” mental disorders
- Division of Insurance has a dedicated mental health parity complaint process
- File complaints at: mass.gov/doi
- Timothy’s Law requires broad mental health coverage
- DFS (Department of Financial Services) enforces parity aggressively
- File complaints at: dfs.ny.gov
- ORS 743A.168 mandates mental health coverage at parity
- Oregon Division of Financial Regulation oversees compliance
- File complaints at: dfr.oregon.gov
How to use parity law when denied TMS
Your TMS claim was denied. Here’s how parity law gives you specific tools to push back.
Step 1: Request the parity comparison
Ask your insurer in writing: “Please provide the comparable medical/surgical treatment limitation and explain how the limitation applied to my TMS request complies with MHPAEA.”
They’re legally required to respond. The answer often reveals the disparity on its own.
Step 2: Spot the disparity
Common parity violations in TMS denials:
- Medication failure requirements: Plan requires 4 failed antidepressants before TMS but only 1 failed medication before comparable medical procedures
- Prior authorization burden: TMS requires extensive documentation that comparable outpatient medical procedures don’t
- Session limits: Plan caps TMS sessions but doesn’t cap comparable medical treatment series (like physical therapy)
Step 3: File a parity complaint
File simultaneously with:
- Your insurer’s internal appeals department — citing specific parity violations
- Your state insurance commissioner — using the contacts above
- CMS (for employer-sponsored plans under ERISA): dol.gov/agencies/ebsa
- Your state attorney general — if the insurer doesn’t respond to the parity request
Filing in multiple places at once creates pressure. That’s the point.
State insurance commissioner contacts
Every state has an insurance commissioner who handles consumer complaints. Key contacts for common TMS states:
| State | Agency | Website |
|---|---|---|
| California | Dept. of Managed Health Care | dmhc.ca.gov |
| Colorado | Division of Insurance | doi.colorado.gov |
| Florida | Office of Insurance Regulation | floir.com |
| Illinois | Dept. of Insurance | insurance.illinois.gov |
| New York | Dept. of Financial Services | dfs.ny.gov |
| Texas | Dept. of Insurance | tdi.texas.gov |
| Massachusetts | Division of Insurance | mass.gov/doi |
| Pennsylvania | Insurance Dept. | insurance.pa.gov |
For other states, search “[your state] department of insurance complaint” to find the filing portal.
Self-insured employer plans: a different path
If your employer self-insures (common at large companies), state laws don’t apply to your plan. Federal law (ERISA) governs instead.
But:
- Federal MHPAEA parity law still applies
- File complaints with the Department of Labor, Employee Benefits Security Administration (EBSA) at dol.gov/agencies/ebsa
- Request your plan’s Summary Plan Description (SPD) and any Clinical Coverage Policies related to TMS
- Self-insured plans sometimes have more flexibility to approve TMS case by case. Talk to your HR department — they have more influence over what the plan covers than you might think
Where TMS coverage is headed
TMS coverage has expanded dramatically since 2018. Every major insurer now covers TMS for depression. Most state Medicaid programs include it. The direction is clear:
- Broader covered diagnoses (OCD is increasingly covered; PTSD and anxiety are under review)
- Fewer medication failure requirements (moving from 4 to 2 failed trials)
- Faster authorization timelines
- State legislation specifically naming TMS as a required benefit — watch for bills in California, New York, and Illinois in upcoming sessions
The system is moving toward more coverage, not less. If you’re fighting for approval right now, the trend is on your side.
Related Insurance Guides
Ready to Explore Your Options?
Browse verified TMS providers, compare clinics, and find the right treatment for your situation.
How to Get TMS Approved
Call the number on the back of your insurance card and ask specifically about TMS therapy coverage. Get a reference number.
Gather records of your MDD diagnosis, all medication trials (names, doses, durations, outcomes), current PHQ-9 score, and therapy history.
Find an in-network TMS provider using our clinic directory. In-network clinics handle prior auth and know your insurer's requirements.
Your TMS clinic submits the prior auth request. Typical approval takes 5-15 business days. If denied, appeal — overturn rates are 60-70%.
What If You’re Denied?
Don't give up after a denial
TMS denial overturn rates are 60-70% on appeal. Steps to take:
- Request a peer-to-peer review — your psychiatrist talks directly to the insurer's medical director
- Submit additional documentation addressing the specific denial reason
- File a formal appeal with your state insurance department if internal appeals fail
- External review — most states allow independent external review of coverage denials
For more details, see our Prior Authorization Guide and Denied Coverage Appeals guide.
Explore TMS List
Treatments & Conditions
Insurance & Cost
-
UnitedHealthcare Coverage
-
Kaiser Permanente Coverage
-
Humana TMS Coverage
- TMS Cost Guide
- TMS Cost Calculator
TMS Specialists
- Jeffrey Shenfeld — Englewood, NJ
- Dr. David Sikowitz — Tinton Falls, NJ
- Gregory Hutton — Tallahassee, FL
- Eric Nicola — Tallahassee, FL