Emma S.
Community Member
No posts yet.
Replied to Struggling with the waiting period before TMS starts
Update — finally started yesterday. The first session was anticlimactic in the best way. The wait is over.
Replied to Just finished my 36-session TMS course — here is my honest review
What was your PHQ-9 before vs after? Trying to track my own progress.
Replied to How long do TMS results typically last?
Stress life event triggered a relapse for me at month 10. Refresher worked. The neural pathways are still there to be re-activated.
Replied to How I got my insurance to cover TMS after initial denial
Aetna approved on first appeal after I cited the APA practice guidelines explicitly. Your provider should know to attach those.
Replied to How long do TMS results typically last?
The Carpenter and Phillip studies are the realistic anchors. ~50-60% maintain response at 12 months without maintenance, higher with.
Replied to TMS for anxiety (not just depression) — my experience
Three weeks in for anxiety primarily. Sleep is the first thing that improved — I'm finally not lying awake replaying conversations.
Replied to New Stanford SAINT protocol showing 90% remission rates — what it means for patients
Stanford's published 1-year follow-up data was less rosy than the headline. Real durability looks closer to standard TMS at 12 months. Still effective, just not magical.
Replied to How I got my insurance to cover TMS after initial denial
Document EVERY medication trial — name, dose, duration, side effect, why you stopped. Insurance lives for that paper trail.
Replied to New Stanford SAINT protocol showing 90% remission rates — what it means for patients
The downside no one mentions: when SAINT works, it works fast — but the rebound risk if you don't have maintenance set up is higher. Have a plan.
Replied to From barely surviving to actually living — TMS changed everything
Six weeks post-course. The plateau between session 10 and 18 was brutal — I thought it wasn't working. Then it clicked.
Replied to How I got my insurance to cover TMS after initial denial
If you're self-pay, ask the clinic about a cash-pay discount. Mine was 40% off the billed rate.
Replied to New Stanford SAINT protocol showing 90% remission rates — what it means for patients
Insurance reality check: BCBS just added accelerated TMS to their coverage policy for treatment-resistant depression. Slow but it's coming.
Replied to How I got my insurance to cover TMS after initial denial
Anthem approved on first appeal after my psychiatrist sent the failed-medication trial table in the format their medical policy specifies. Format matters.
Replied to Just finished my 36-session TMS course — here is my honest review
Did you have any cognitive side effects? Brain fog? I've read mixed things.
Replied to How I got my insurance to cover TMS after initial denial
United denied me three times. The thing that finally worked: a letter from my therapist documenting functional impairment (work, relationships, ADLs).
Replied to TMS for anxiety (not just depression) — my experience
I'm about to start TMS and have both anxiety and depression. Did your doctor discuss doing both sides? I'm trying to understand what to ask about at my consultation next week.
Replied to Struggling with the waiting period before TMS starts
Sending you strength, Mike. I was in the same spot 4 months ago. Now I'm on session 24 and feeling better than I have in years. The wait is temporary.
Replied to From barely surviving to actually living — TMS changed everything
One year strong! That's amazing. I'm 3 months post-treatment and feeling good but nervous about it fading. Your post gives me hope that the changes can stick.
Replied to How I got my insurance to cover TMS after initial denial
Same experience with UnitedHealthcare. First denial, then approved on appeal with documentation of 4 failed meds. The whole process took about 6 weeks. One thing I'd add: ask for a peer-to-peer review. That's where your psychiatrist talks directly to the insurance company's reviewing doctor. My psychiatrist said that call is what turned things around.